The 3 leaks costing them the most
1 The H1 is just the brand name
Why it hurts: The actual H1 is 'Carrd' β the value prop lives in the tagline below (#7, #20). A skimmer reads a logo, not a promise.
Fix: Promote 'Simple, free, one-page sites for pretty much anything' into the H1 slot.
2 It shows almost nothing
Why it hurts: 10 images, no video, no live demo (#10, #25) for a product whose whole appeal is how good the sites look.
Fix: Show three gorgeous example sites built with Carrd, right up top.
3 No proof at all
Why it hurts: No testimonials, no user count, no founder (#15, #29). A wildly popular tool is hiding every shred of social proof.
Fix: Add a 'made with Carrd' gallery and a simple user-count stat.
All 31 principles, scored
Free up to three sites, with a cheap Pro tier β a softer monetization signal.
Fix: Front the Pro value sooner.
No color clutter detected β extremely minimal.
'three sites', '$19', 'dozens of templates' bring some numbers.
Fix: Add a user or site-count stat.
Minimal footer with little personality.
Fix: Add a hook.
Has an og:image but the OG title and description are empty.
Fix: Fill the OG title with the tagline.
Simple / Responsive / Free β each section holds one clean idea.
The H1 is just 'Carrd'; the plain tagline does the real work.
Fix: Promote the tagline to the H1.
Free signup fronts the funnel; Pro upgrade comes later.
Fix: Anchor the Pro decision earlier.
'for pretty much anything' and 'yup β totally free' carry a casual voice.
Fix: Add a line only Carrd's maker could write.
Only 10 images and no demo β the output is barely shown.
Fix: Add an example-site gallery.
One job: one-page sites. Beautifully focused.
A few Pro tiers stay within the popcorn range.
Fix: Make the recommended tier obvious.
Rides the link-in-bio / simple-site wave.
Fix: None.
'for pretty much anything', 'yup' is exactly the casual user's voice.
No founder presence despite being a famous solo-founder product.
Fix: Add a maker note.
'Go Pro!' exists in the menu but pricing isn't a clear nav item.
Fix: Add a plain 'Pricing' link.
'for pretty much anything' is the sticky phrase.
Fix: Build the headline around it.
Low-key emotional pull.
Fix: Add a spark of delight.
Carrd effectively defined the simple-one-pager niche.
Fix: Show the never-seen ease.
The tagline conveys what it is, but the H1 doesn't carry it.
Fix: Fix the H1.
Little pain-naming before the pitch.
Fix: Name the pain of bloated site builders.
'Choose a Starting Point' is the single, clear primary action.
'Carrd' is a distinct, memorable name.
Sells simplicity and free β ease as desire.
Fix: Sell the status of a clean personal site.
Free signup lets you build immediately.
Only one weak word detected.
Pro is an annual subscription, though cheap.
Fix: Offer a lifetime option.
'Choose a Starting Point' says exactly what happens next.
Testimonial markup exists but no visible quotes or proof.
Fix: Add a 'made with Carrd' gallery.
The tagline describes it in under ten words.
Cheap, free-led pricing β the opposite of premium.
Fix: Consider a premium-feeling Pro tier.
How would your page score?
Same 31 principles. Same brutal honesty. Free.
Grade My Page